Tuesday, June 7, 2011

The Controversy in Visual Culture

      In the article “Rescuing Art from Visual Culture Studies”, the author Michelle Marder Kamhi firmly argued that Visual Culture has ruined Art education so it has to be separated from Art. She believes that Visual Culture emphasizes too much on bad feelings like anger, resentment and moral outrage by unnecessarily focusing on social or political issues.  
    While I read the article, I was persuaded in few points which referred to impure purpose or intention of Visual Culture such as commercial and incidentally or accidentally created things such as photography. However, Kamhi tends to have too strict perspective to define or distinguish art so it seems to be hard to take it into today’s art classroom where a lot of needs and topics exist to deal with. Her ideal Art class includes much less activity than the Art class adopting Visual Culture as a main concern in curriculum of Art education. 
   She also seems to have some conservative prejudice about postmodernism genres such as pop art. Even though I agree with her assertion that Visual culture doesn’t have honorable sprits or purposes and, sometimes, is dependant heavily on machinery, I want to make sure of that these genres also have same goals to pursue more creative, newer, and more beautiful things. Especially, in art education, the reason why Visual Culture Studies is significant is that it helps students get actively involved into class through discussion or debate about art work related to social, political controversy.
    In Chapter 2 Facilitating Investigations into Historical, Cultural and Social Context, the author takes care of a lot of concerns related Visual Culture and proposes the effective ways to conduct theses issues in Art classroom. Traditionally, most of them were not supposed to be the concerns with Art education because, basically, the topics are accustomed to have interdisciplinary connections. Some of them, sometimes, are closer to History or Social studies rather than Art. Nevertheless, there must be good reasons why the Art education has to handle the issues.  
    I found an article which could be a good example of refutation against Kamhi’s article and demonstrates why Art has to deal with Visual Culture at school. The title of article is Using Visual Culture, Socially Minded Projects, and Student Driven Courses to Support Democracy written by Margaret Tunner who is a student in Visual Art education at Eastern Michigan University. http://www.emich.edu/coe/powerplay/docs/vol_2/issue_1/107_111_turner.pdf
   In her article, before asserting the importance of Visual Culture, she points out what is the purpose of education. She said one of important reasons of education is socialization which instructs students on conduct that is valued by our society and citizens should be educated in the not only the workings of democratic processes, but also in the ways of active participation in the means and communication that support democratic involvement.
   She also believes that Visual Culture education could be a great way to satisfy the basic purpose of education. According to Tunner, engagement in visual media culture, socially and ethically minded projects, and student driven coursework would allow students to develop the skills for democratic and community participation. In addition, analyzing images through historical, cultural, social and consumer contexts allows student to see the power relations among group and the interrelations of multiple culture.
   I believe that there must be something different aspects or perception between Art and Art education. I don’t think I am capable of defining or distinguishing Art but, at least, I believe that I know well about what the goal of Art education is and the reason why Art education is essential to young generation. Art couldn’t be separated from everything but could be a great method to analyze our society or another study and help students develop their critical thinking and problem solving skill. This process totally corresponds with the purpose of education.  Kamhi seems to ignore the educational effectiveness through adopting Visual Culture.  
 I want to think more about different definition between Art and Art education during the class because this could be a key to refute Kamhi’s argument. So my questions are as follow.
1.      What kinds of benefits can students gain through studying Visual Culture?
2.      How are Art studies and Art education different?
  

1 comment:

  1. Excellent response to Kahmi. Your argument along with tanner that schooling is about socialization is powerful:    In her article, before asserting the importance of Visual Culture, she points out what is the purpose of education. She said one of important reasons of education is socialization which instructs students on conduct that is valued by our society and citizens should be educated in the not only the workings of democratic processes, but also in the ways of active participation in the means and communication that support democratic involvement.

    ReplyDelete