Showing posts with label Curriculum. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Curriculum. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 10, 2012

Refelction #10 Meaning


Man’s main concern is not to gain pleasure or to avoid pain but rather to see a meaning in his life. Our fundamental drive, the motivational engine that powers human existence, is the pursuit of meaning. (Frankl)

In this chapter, Pink explains why meaning is an essential aptitude for Conceptual Age through using various quotations and examples. He points out that we have the luxury of devoting more of our lives to the search for meaning, freed from the struggle for survival. I perfectly agree with his perspective when comparing my parents’ life to my life. My parents have seemed to have less time to look for meaning of their life because they have spent most time for making money to raise their kids and pay bills which is sympathetic to me as a their child. They might want to spend more time to look for meaning of the life through studying or any other spiritual activities but it was almost impossible for my parents’ generation. However, thanks to abundance given by my parents, I could have enough time to look for meaning of the life from the early age. The reason I decided to study abroad is also strongly related to the process to look for meaning of the life. I believe my child would put more emphasis on looking for meaning as the future society is more abundant so survival is no longer a matter at all. Even though meaning as an essential aptitude for Conceptual age’s society is more ambiguous and abstract to understand compared to any other senses, I could understand why meaning would be chosen for one of Pink’s new mind. It is certainly true in contemporary society too that the more the quality of life is improved, the more time human being spends for looking for meaning.       

While Pink talks about meaning in the view of business, I have been thinking and trying to understand meaning in the view of education. Is education fully taking care of meaning in the process of learning? Are young students able to look for meaning through current education system, principles or curriculums? I personally believe current education hardly put a premium on looking for meaning or making meaning. It still focuses on acquiring knowledge and information. While making and looking for meaning involves the active process of introspection, self-discovery and self-realization, acquiring knowledge and information is more like the passive process of accepting other people’s discoveries or meanings. In terms of that, arts as a subject should take a main role in education. Arts involve the active process to look for meaning which could provide a chance for students to explore meaning through examining and analyzing one's own thoughts and feelings.

As Pink mentioned, I also believe that making the transition from the Information Age to the Conceptual age, moving from a landscape of L-Directed Thinking to one of R-Directed Thinking, adding the capacity for art and heart to our penchant for logic and analysis, won’t be easy. However, since many people starts to be aware of these new values, I don’t think it will take too much time for the world to accept the new values.

Wednesday, March 21, 2012

Reflection #9 Symphony

  In this chapter, Pink explains why symphony is becoming essential aptitude for today’s and future society with great examples. I absolutely agree with his assertion. He points out that the reason symphony is being significantly important is because automation has taken over many of the routine analytic tasks that knowledge workers once performed. No wonder that in today’s society, creator or inventor much more easily take center stage than excellent operator or technician. I personally think the distinct difference between these two types of people is that while one has original and creative idea, other one only accepts and master it. As Pink writes that innovation comes from the ability to synthesize, I believe creativity also requires the ability to put together the pieces.

  His anecdote about drawing is interesting. What he points out is that I have never thought of before. He said that one of the best ways to understand and develop the aptitude of Symphony is to learn how to draw. His conclusion is that “drawing is largely about relationships.” Even though I haven’t thought that way before, I now understand what the ability to draw requires. Understand relationships between elements! I have almost same experience with Pink. I was also frustrated when I realized that my drawing is much worse than I have expected. Ironically I haven’t notice that before entering art education program.  

 Like drawing, Symphony is largely about relationships. People who hope to thrive in the Conceptual Age must understand the connections between diverse and seemingly separate, discipline. They must know how to link apparently unconnected elements to create something new. (Pink)

Symphony has many in common with “multi”. As Pink said, our jobs require multitasking, our communities are multicultural and our entertainment is multimedia. As the world is becoming smaller, this tendency would be expanded and strengthened. Multiplayer and multitasker would be much more competitive. He calls these people boundary crossers. According to his definition, boundary crossers mean types of people who develop expertise in multiple spheres, speak different languages, and find joy in the rich variety of human experience. It sounds very idealistic but I am a little relieved because at least I am bilingual and this experience of studying abroad and living in the different culture for long time would be very beneficial and valuable for me to become a boundary crosser.  

His portfolio is a quite excellent way to develop powers of Symphony. To me, the more interesting practices are 1) Hit the Newsstand, 2) Keep a metaphor log, 3) Draw and 4) Create an inspiration board. As soon as I read these practices, something important idea initially come in mind. That was that these kinds of activities would be great choices for art class and art class could perfectly cover these activities. This is inspiring because I know that would mean art class helps students develop powers of symphony which is essential ability in new conceptual age.


Monday, March 12, 2012

Reflection #8 - Story

  I have loved stories in every creation. While watching movies, reading novels, studying history and appreciating artworks, I could meet the fascinating stories in them which help me have a better understanding about not only the world but also myself. This chapter reminds me of my school days. I used to love make up and write a story. I was once in a trouble because I was writing a story during the music class. The teacher took the notebook from me and quickly read it. Then she called me and said “Even though this story is interesting but it is totally wasted on you. You’d better focus on preparing a test.” Eventually, I never got back my notebook. Maybe, because of this kind of experience, I might start to have bias toward story. I had been naturally accepted the idea that story is not really related to intellectual works as Pink mentioned that there are many people believing that stories amuse; facts illuminate, stories divert; facts reveal and stories for cover; facts are for real. However, my perspective has slowly changed after graduation. Even though, story hasn’t been important in school, I found that there were many places outside the school which earnestly need great stories. During this art education master’s program, inspired by many experiences, I could completely recognize the importance of story in education. 

“Stories are easier to remember- because in many ways, stories are how we remember. “Narrative imagining-story- is the fundamental instrument of thought.” (Pink)

”Rational capacities depend on it. It is our chief means of looking into the future of predicting, of planning and explaining… Most of our experience, our knowledge and our thinking are organized as stories. Story is just as integral to the human experience as design.” (Mart Tuner)

“Humans are not ideally set up to understand logic; they are ideally set up to understand stories.”
(Roger C. SCHANK)

  There are many reasons why story is significant and essential in education. I personally believe the most important reason story is valuable is because it can contain imagination. It could be considered a fake when it has strong imagination in it however, that doesn’t mean it is not valuable. That’s because human initially used imagination to come up with totally new ideas for the innovative inventions all around us even though they are easily taken for granted now such as car, air plane, movie, TV, smart phone, internet and etc. The stories containing this kind of invention used to be considered as someone else’s fake at some point in the past.    

  In terms of importance of story, arts would be the most effective education method in school curriculum. Art education cares about stories artworks contains and how to use stories involving imagination because is often used for understanding artworks and myself as an artist. As Pink mentioned, it is easier for many people to remember when they learn something through story it contain. Besides, it lasts so long. The information which is memorized during the short term wouldn’t last that long unless learner repeats or add personal experience to it because it focus primarily on memorization rather than understanding. While having VTS classes with my students, I have been very impressed how much efficiently narrative is used for higher level thinking. My students were continually developing and now they can make many various narratives, seeing the photograph only focusing on figure’s facial expression. Their stories are not only mixed with imagination based on cultural contexts, their experiences and background information but also work with emotions. The story activates their thinking skills, imagination and creativity. This has been a beneficial experience to me as a future art educator because I am convinced that the ability to encapsulate, contextualize and emotionalize which are required for the Conceptual Age could perfectly be developed through art education.  

The story is one of the basic tools invented by the human mind for the purpose of understanding. There have been great societies that did not use the wheel, but there have been no societies that did not tell the stories. (URSULA K. LE GUIN)

Monday, March 5, 2012

Letter from the photograph


Jooyoung,


   I have known that you have remembered me well for a long time. And I understand that you are afraid of watching me because of savageness I contain and the tragedy caused by me. Sadly enough, I could only give you heart breaking sorrow and pain rather than pleasure and joy. While, as a mother of a kid, you are crying in your mind while looking at the dying toddler, I was also crying because of the sense of guilt.
   Many people said that I didn’t deserve to win Pulitzer Prize because they believe my owner broke the basic duty of human being. Yes. He let the vulture wait the child to die because he as an artist was obsessed with the desire to create art which makes people aware of the severe reality. As you know, blamed by many people, my owner had depressed and eventually killed himself. After the tragedy, I have also suffered from deep depression.
   I heard today what you said to comfort me. Thank you for saying that you appreciate that I made you aware of the reality of many dying children because of starvation. And I am very happy and proud of you to keep donating for starving children. That also made me relieved since I feel like I am valuable enough to inspire people.
 I hope I could meet soon again. Next time, both of us would be more comfortable with it.

Love always,



       

Reflection #7, Design


In this chapter, Pink explained why design is one of the six senses required for being a successful individual of the contemporary and future society by using understandable but surprising examples. Agreeing with many points, I have also realized that the realm of design is much wider than I have thought. I especially agree that even if we could hardly notice all the time, design has been strongly related to everything all around us. This idea also reminds me of the activity in the last class. I and the peers discussed about what makes art or how to distinguish art object or non-art object. Most of us eventually concluded that the objects which intentionally designed by human being would be an art object regardless of purpose. Since we collected objects from the places close at hand, except the objects from nature, I personally thought many of them would be clearly identified by the term, design, rather than art. While reading this chapter, I looked around the room and found that every object has a particular shapes, colors, patterns and sizes which are considered as elements of design. Besides, every design certainly contains ideas as Nuovo mentioned that “Design in its simplest form is the activity of creating solutions. Design is something that everyone does every day.”

“Design, stripped to its essence, can be defined as the human nature to shape and make our environment in ways without precedent in nature, to serve our needs and give meaning to our lives.” (John Heskett)

I feel the same way about the phenomenon of the democracy of design Pink points out. As technology has rapidly developed, more individuals not only possess and deal with programs of personal devices or media which are strongly influenced by the elements of design but also have a higher expectation and understanding in terms of design toward every object. As a consumer, more people have started to put more emphasis on design when they choose the products. Besides, regardless of the kinds of job, the level of dependence on design is getting higher. Because of these changes, I believe education should not hesitate to reflect this tendency and changes like CHAD Pink exemplified. Art curriculum has to contain more activities for students to explore and practice to create their own design as well as schools, policy makers, educators and parents need to put premium on art as a major subject in school curriculum because learning design in school curriculum could provide students chances to develop their design sensibility for future career.    

In Korean education, art and design seem to be somewhat separated since art curriculums still tend to focus on fine arts even though visual culture started to receive attention as a new concept for art education. Art classes deals with design but it is general and not enough for students to develop their design sensibility. Rather than general education, design has taught in many kinds of private institutions in Korea. They provide high quality curriculum and professionally teach students who want to have a career related to design. The thing is while these private educations are rapidly developed, the general education hasn’t fully accepted the democracy of design. I believe Korean education has to strengthen the visual culture education that emphasizes design in order for students to prepare their future.       

“The wealth of nations and the well-being of individuals now depend on having artists in the room. In a world enriched by abundance but disrupted by automation and outsourcing of white color work, everyone, regardless of profession, must cultivate an artistic sensibility. We may not all be Dali or Degas. But today we must all be designers.” (Pink)

At the end of chapter, what Pink suggested for developing design sensibility would be very interesting and intriguing to me as a future art teacher such as Keep a Design Notebook, Channel Your Annoyance, Become a Design Detective, Put in on a Table and Be choosy. They all contain very creative and brilliant ideas. I thought that these practices would be not only very beneficial for me to have design sensibility but also efficient for my future students to develop their creativity as well as design sensibility.   


Wednesday, February 29, 2012

Reflection #6


How are the 2 artifacts (structure and photo) different? Similar?
 Two artifacts could basically be similar since the photo has dealt with the same structure. But it is normally somewhat different as every photograph is not exactly same as the real objects. The photograph could strongly influenced by light, angle, view or technique so it is intentionally created according to particular concepts or could, sometimes, shows the form of distortion of the truth which is far from reality. Photograph could certainly make and create meaning differently from reality. Because of that, I agree that photography would absolutely be considered as art.   


How does your vision translate from 3D to 2D?
 From this experience, I realized that seeing the object through my eyes when I actually observed the structure is very different from seeing and understanding 2D image such as photograph and picture. Unlike the visual experience with 3D which enables me to keep expanding meanings by understanding sequence or context, the 2D version looks much more simple, limited and abstract. It could enable me to focus on understanding the particular part of object in detail.   

  
Does this process change the way you SEE the structure?
 Yes. Through this experience, the way to see and understand the structure is pretty much changed. Deconstructing, combining and designing the structures, I have better understanding about the characteristics of the structures. Besides, through creating the 2D version of the structure by using light, color and angle, I got to understand how photography could make meanings intentionally or unintentionally. I thought the 3D image of structure resembles a rollercoaster but 2D image is much harder to be understood since it is more ambiguous, abstract and mysterious.    

Why do artists play?
 From this exciting experience, I understand the reasons why artists play. I personally believe that the concept of play would include exploration and experiment. Through freely playing, they might encounter new findings and, by extension, could develop the new findings into artistic repertories. Thus, play could be a new attempt to meet something new.   


How has playing with paper reinforced the importance of play?
  While making the self supporting structures and combining three structures, I subconsciously participated in meaning making process. Even though a peace of paper itself would be meaningless object, the structure of paper which is made by creator could turn into art. There were no objects which are strongly intended at first, but the process of combining structure seemed to be the process to create meaningful objects.    

What did you learn about play in this class?
 Participating in the play, I realized that play is certainly open to a lot of possibilities in terms of medium and concepts. Play could bring inspirations to artists and provide various chances and possibilities to find aesthetic value from new experiments.  


After viewing Olivia Gude’s the PostModern Principle of PLAYING.
  The Postmodern Principle of Playing contains the valuable ideas about play which I also learned from this experience. I totally agree that learning begins as deeply personal, primary process play. As she mentioned, I also believe that such play must be truly free, not directed toward mastering a technique, solving a specific problem, or illustrating a randomly chosen juxtaposition in order to efficiently encounter new findings.  
Seeing a lot of examples of play, I was very impressed because they are totally new experiments I haven’t ever dealt with. Since the creative process of play requires higher level of thinking, the experiences would be a great chance for students to have ability to toy with elements and concepts which is need when developing not only thinking skills but also creativity.



Tuesday, February 21, 2012

Reflection #5

Pink’s Chapter 1 titled Right brain rising, was so interesting and easy to understand. I fully enjoyed reading and through this chapter, I could learn in detail about the functions of right and left hemisphere, how they works and how they cooperate while we encounter something to think, guess and interpret. Even if I roughly know that certain regions of the brain are more active than others when it comes to certain functions, it was still beneficial enough since I could connect this idea to importance of arts education. I perfectly agree with Pink’s claim that the popular believes that the function of right hemisphere is somewhat inferior to those of left hemisphere are wrong and those functions are not confined to particular areas.

As I expected, according to Pink’s scientific investigations like many other researches, learning art depends more on the function of right hemisphere rather than those of left hemisphere because art would mostly be dealt simultaneously and understood visually and in context. I believe these characteristics make art unique and valuable. As Pink mentioned, even though left hemisphere was fully activated if there’s no function of right hemisphere, nobody could have various works successfully or artistically done. That is because the left hemisphere only specializes in text but cannot specialize in context which the right hemisphere could deal with. Learning visual culture and visual literacy at the classes, I realized that how active and efficient learning occurs based on cooperation and harmony of both hemispheres of brain. For instance, using a multimodal composition which consists of both language and image or text and context could be a good method to provide students a chance to use both hemispheres in order to more critically successfully develop the ideas than when using only one hemisphere. This is what art classes are doing.   

In Korea, It has been over 10 years since the term, EQ(emotional quotient) has been very popular not only in the field of education but also in the various field that requires creativity and imagination. The educators and researchers initially placed premium on the importance of function of right hemisphere in a protest against the dominance of IQ. And their conclusion of researches that EQ as well as IQ is very important when learning something or for being a successful person has been widely believed. I assume this kind of change occurred as a result of that the perception toward the professional in art related field changed in a positive way. It is a very encouraging change to me as an art educator but it is still a shame because this new educational trend fully applies to only early childhood education but not to whole level of education.

Since it is the most important to harmoniously activate both hemispheres of brain for better educational achievements, I believe art have to be more emphasized in the current education. Besides art would be only one of the few subjects which help students use both sides brain which     designed to work together as a smooth, singe, integrated whole in one entire complete brain as Pink mentioned.  


Eisner’s chapter 6 not only described how the ideal curriculum looks like but also point out how wrongly standards work in the curriculum as a restriction. I was especially interested in the way Eisner claims about an appropriate role or function of standard every teacher deals with. Besides, it is good enough to persuade me to think the same way. However, one thing I was confused was about the part he claimed that criteria would be more appropriate for art curriculum than standards.  That is because criteria and standards have exactly same meaning in Korean. So I tried to read the paragraph several times and finally could understand what he meant. If criteria were more open and flexible and enabled students and teachers to deeply investigate the concepts or ideas, I also agree that criteria definitely need to be considered as the important concept in the curriculum.         

What the field needs are criteria rather than standards. If standards are conceived of as fixed models of outcomes, then their appropriateness in a domain in which ingenuity and imagination are important is questionable. Criteria, however, are ideas that prompt a teacher or evaluator to inquire into the work at hand in order to discern its educational and aesthetic value. Criteria invite inquiry; they do not close it off. (Eisner)

Reading this chapter, I have thought about the standards in art education in Korean. In the case of Korean art education, there are also many kinds of standards the Ministry of Education provides. And most teachers tend to consider the standards as a model of outcome or goal. Compared to those of America, from my experience with general education, it is more conservative and rigorous about the application of standards. I perfectly agree with Eisner that standards can be a major asset to teachers if the school provides them with the time and support needed to discuss with their colleagues the meaning of standards and the possibility of different standards for different populations, different schools and different students. However, unfortunately, this could hardly happen to the field of education in Korea because of various invisible restrictions such as lack of time, efforts or illiberal atmosphere. Even if teachers cannot afford to have the meaningful process to critically check the standards with their colleagues, it would be beneficial if each teacher uses standards as considerations for curriculum development without unquestioningly absorbing.

Through the Chapter 6, Freedman points out why teaching visual culture is important in contemporary democratic society in which involves more complex systems of freedom, individualism, equity and social responsibility.

Changes in art education can promote the transformation of cultural representations in school at large and effectively help educators to meet democratic goals. A visual culture curriculum is a collage for learning that illuminates and demonstrates an awareness of the fragile and fragmentary state of much contemporary cultural knowledge, as well as the resilience of cultural tradition. (Freedman)

I was especially impressed by Figure 6.2 Example scope and sequence for teaching visual culture. It gave me a chance to think how I could give a shape to teaching visual culture according to the levels and organizers as well as to have a better understanding about scope and sequence of visual culture. Interesting thing is that it shows how many concepts related to visual culture in democratic society could be dealt with in art education and how the ideas could be developing as the level goes up. Because of these advantages of art curriculum in teaching visual culture, I think teaching visual culture in any study need to take into account art-related curriculum in order to efficiently and fully understand cultural contexts.     




Monday, February 13, 2012

Reflection #4

In the chapter5, demonstrating why teaching visual culture is important today and how beneficial it would be to young students, Freedman asserts that visual culture needs to be widely applied to the school curriculum. This chapter was especially advantageous for me because I could think deeply about how I could deal with visual culture in the classroom as an essential concept of today art education.

I agree with her that our world seems to be increasingly saturated by visual culture that influences students at all educational level. As a mother, I was very empathetic by her examples that even preschooler could recognize enormous images of popular visual culture. From my experience, that is really true. My four years old daughter has started to notice everything around her such as particular advertisements, symbols, logos, brands, music, movies and games and begun to make meaning by mixing those. This is pretty surprising to me because I didn’t teach many of them. It seems like the specific filter of visual culture works on the process of cognition of our children.  

I used to believe that where I could efficiently learn arts would be museum or art galleries as many people do. But influenced by learning visual culture, my perspective has been totally changed. There must be something important that cannot be taught in those places. I believe even though students have a good understating about particular works of art or art history, the students would not understand an aspect of whole culture and cultural interactions if they don’t have ability to extend meaning or make multiple meaning through cultural context. In terms of that, new concepts of arts are crossing many types of old boundaries. It could be a bit wide and vast but it could help young students to develop knowledge to make intelligent decisions about what they encounter and see and the ways where visual culture will influence them.

Developing ideas while reading this chapter, I came up with the idea that teaching visual culture would be strongly related to visual literacy. Unlike today’s high rates of literacy, there are so many people who can’t not read and interpret visual images successfully because current education doesn’t provide students a chance to develop visual literacy skill as well as to learn visual culture. Thinking about the relationship between visual culture and visual literacy, I identified that if the visual culture was enormous source or information, having visual literacy skill would be the purpose of learning visual culture because visual literacy mean that the ability to interpret, negotiate, and make meaning from information presented in the form of an image. Without having a good understanding about visual culture, nobody can have a good visual literacy since it is almost impossible for viewers to understand complex images without extending meaning by using knowledge of visual culture.   

Art education should help students reflect on the seductive power of visual culture so that they become aware of the continual learning that is part of their daily contact with it. Students can become conscious of the ways in which they construct their own knowledge through their encounters with forms of visual culture. (Freedman)


Eisner demonstrates how children’s cognitive development takes place in the artmaking process in the chapter 5. Giving various examples and introducing many theories, he explained how artmaking process contributes to children’s cognitive developments. I was very impressed by his demonstration and got a chance to make a connection with the importance of learning visual culture.

Social norms, models for behavior, opportunities to converse and share one’s work with others are also opportunities to learn. This broad social conception of the sources of what, where, and how children learn, not only in the arts but in all areas, is referred to as situated learning; the child is situated in a social and material context and this context viewed as a culture. (Eisner)

Before making the unit plan during the last overview class, I didn’t know how many concepts and considerations would be associated and get together in the process prior to artmaking. I simply thought that art lessons might be less complicated and conceptual but it was completely wrong. Realizing how hard to create art lessons, I am, now, convinced that students can get various benefits from well-designed artmaking. Since good art lessons require higher level of thinking, students can definitely develop not only creativity or imagination but also cognitive skill through the whole process.

Interested in seeing children’s drawing as examples of cognitive development, I was able to fully aware that techniques required when making arts also reflect ways of thinking about the thing to be done. I actually haven’t thought of that before but thinking about the children who I observe during the internship, I couldn’t help but totally agree with it. Needless to say, through investigating new techniques, students might develop creativity and thinking skills. I think I could answer now if I was asked why acquisition of techniques would be important in art education.    

The acquisition of the technique is not merely a technical achievement. It is a mode of thought; and as such the changing feature in children’s artwork is the result of changes in the way in which they think about what they are doing. What we see in children’s artwork, particularly when it is laid out over time, is the progression of the development of such thinking. (Eisner)



Tuesday, February 7, 2012

Reflection #3

Along with the topic, what is art and what is not art, in the last class, Freedman’s chapter3 gave me a chance to think how I can deal with visual culture as art in my classroom. It is certainly not easy because first I need to root out bias toward art which was caused by my own art education I have gotten. During my formal education, I haven’t been taught visual culture as well as haven’t dealt with popular culture in the classroom (even though most kids got into popular culture during adolescence.) Only a few decades ago, the classroom was one of the most conservative places in Korea. Therefore, what I have learned except this MU art education program would be significantly different from what I am going to teach for today’s young children.     

Foundations of educational change come from new academic histories of the visual arts which help to frame discussions of diversity and social meaning, but also come from outside of academic structures to personal stories and visual culture in daily life. (Freedman)

Being in agreement with what Freedman mentioned, I looked back on the time when I decided to apply MU art education program. Until that time, I didn’t expect that I would be going to learn is what I am learning now. This is actually more incredible and exciting than I expected. I thought I couldn’t connect this program to my undergraduate studies, journalism and to other experiences I had in the field of advertisements and publications. But my fears are utterly groundless and I am glad to study this new aspect of art education. As Freedman points out, things are certainly changed and, I believe, they need to keep changing. While reading this chapter, I have a better understanding how visual culture come to the center of art education from the border area.     

However, in contemporary democracies, these conceptual boundaries have been challenged, revealing that an education in visual culture must include an opening up of disciplinary boundaries if we want students to understand ways in which the past lives in the present and future. (Freedman)

From my internship experience in the elementary school in America, art education in Korea still tends to put the more emphasis on fine art than visual culture. Besides visual culture is not very popular term as compared with those of America. Elementary school art curriculum would be more open to visual or popular culture but middle school and high school art curriculum are less open toward visual culture. According to Freedman, art education of Korea seems to stick to old art history since it still love to deal with the narrow influence of individual objects and style on fine art.

“The new art history is quite different from the old art history. Less important is the narrow influence of individual objects and styles on subsequent fine art and more important are the social influences and dynamics of culture development. It shifts attention away from connoisseurship as the basic method of teaching about the past in art education.” (Freedman)

But as compared with the past when I was in school, the aspect of art education is also remarkably changed because the Education Ministry, schools and educators started to recognize the importance of teaching visual culture for students to understand social influences and culture development. The change in the perception of art or artist in Korea is also surprising. Most people consider the professionals who work in the field of popular culture and get a remarkable achievement as an artist and admire their status. Because of these changes inside and outside school, it would be absolutely beneficial for me to study visual culture in order to not only help my students to understand the production and use of visual culture but also prepare their future life in the real world which is rapidly changing. .

In the chapter 4, Freedman brought various educational theories and researches in order to demonstrate how the cognition through visual experiences would be connected to the real learning process. There were pretty many things I didn’t totally understand but I think I understand what she points out in terms of teaching visual culture.  

“Teaching visual culture is not just a matter of selecting the images and objects to include in curriculum. It involves changes in the instructional methods used to enact curriculum, changes that should respond to the new understanding of cognition as well as traditional methods that have been demonstrated to work. These methods should take into account the variety of experiences people have with visual culture and how those experiences direct learning.” (Freedman)

As she mention that much less attention has been give to the relationship between cognition and the arts, I think art have been marginalized in schools because of that reason. I ashamed to say that I haven’t thought that studying art is strongly related to cognition before I got to experience Visual Thinking Strategies. But through studying Housen’s research about aesthetic development and observing my students in VTS class, I have a better understanding about the relation between arts and cognition which is the mental process involved in knowing, learning, and understanding things. The most different thing between other subjects and art would be that art cares much more about human emotion. Unlike people’s prejudice toward using emotion in learning, I believe emotion never interrupts the process of cognition but helps students find cognitive connection as she mentioned.

“Emotion in school subjects other than art is usually considered best left at the classroom door where cognition, without ties to emotion, supposedly takes over. However, learning takes place based on cognitive connections, including those that relate to emotion and more connections mean greater learning. Learning is dependent on student engagement, which is an indicator of emotional investment.” (Freedman)


Tuesday, January 31, 2012

Reflection2 & Bumper Sticker


Eisner’s two chapters dealt with how to teach visual art and how to create effective learning environment through teaching art. While reading these two chapters, I have thought of many points in current education as well as art education and met a lot of agreeable moments from my experiences as a student. As Eisner mentioned that two of the most important factors affecting students’ experiences in the classroom are the quality of teaching they encounter and the quality of the curriculum provided, I have been wondering how to enhance the quality of teaching and curriculum since I have got into the field of education. Because these two factors basically came from capacity of the teachers, the students’ educational achievements could be varied according to what kind of teachers they meet.

“Good teaching cannot be “delivered”. Teaching like knowledge cannot be shipped, pumped or transmitted like the contents of a letter into the heads of students. In a sense, all that teachers can do is to make noises in the environment.”(Eisner)

I smiled when reading the above paragraph since it reminds me my school experiences through the childhood. Many teachers seemed to believe teaching as a delivery tool of knowledge so that, they were so passionate to make noises literally. Sadly enough I, sometimes, considered what they said as “noises”. That was because, I believe, the appropriate learning environment and situation couldn’t be created by teachers. During the internship course, the most important thing I had learned is that teacher’s role is not only to teach but also create positive learning environments and situation which effectively engages students in meaningful learning process connected new aspects of outside the classroom.

“Another important idea about teaching is that its most important effects are located outside the classroom. To the extent to which are interested in their ability to use what they have learned in life outside school- the context that really matters we must look to their behavior outside school.” (Eisner)

Influenced by the generalization of Internet and personal multimedia devices, today’s students are accustomed to actively learning outside the school. They are not passive receivers anymore but the school curriculum hasn’t taken this new aspect and change of the world. They don’t really care how students use their knowledge or skills they learned from the school in the outside the school. Most schools still stick to standardized tests in order to evaluate students as if the tests’ scores were good predictors of what students will do outside school. Besides, the tests focus primarily on assessing the immediate effects. But Eisner points out that it, sometimes, takes a little bit long time being fully aware and having a better understanding about what students have learn. Learning is not paused but being progress by interacting with various factors such as new knowledge and experiences.

Then, what can we teach through the arts and what can students get benefits from learning the arts? I personally believe that the most important thing students can get from the art classes is to learn and experience how to use their imagination for the active learning. Through this process, students could develop their creativity and perspective toward the new world. Because of that, the teachers’ ability to engage students’ imagination is critically important skill in art teaching.  Another outcome of effective art education is the refinement of perception as Eisner discussed. Because Students who have been in an effective arts education program should have had their sensibilities refined.

Freedman’s chapter is very challenging for me to understand. I have recognized the historical aspects of teaching visual culture but I couldn’t make meaning between the concepts and theories as well as couldn’t have a good understanding for that. So I focused on reading the conclusion several times in order to get the main points that she wanted to say. And I finally found the last sentence that Dewey mentioned.
“We come to know art through the dynamic of experience but experience has changed” (Dewey)



The Bumper Sticker

Eisner states Good teaching cannot be “delivered”. Teaching like knowledge cannot be shipped, pumped or transmitted like the contents of a letter into the heads of students.

Tuesday, January 24, 2012

Reflection #1

    While and after reading EISNER’s two chapter, The Role of The Arts in Transforming Consciousness and Vision and Versions of Art education, I have a chance to think of many points and perspectives it suggests. He starts the first chapter with demonstrating the importance of the arts in the human society by using scientific evidences. According to EISNER human being experiences, learns and develops the world by using the fully advanced sensory. Because of the sensory, human can build a wide range of distinct cultures and its aspects that have improved the society.      

“But the sensory system does not work alone: it requires for its development the tools of culture: language, the art, science, values and the like. With the aid of culture we learn how to create ourselves. (EISNER, p2)”

   Based on this point of view, he figures out how the arts work for human society and how arts have affected on our consciousness. From his perspective, work in the art is not only a way of creating performances but also creating our lives by expanding our consciousness, shaping our dispositions, satisfying our quest for meaning, establishing contact with others and sharing a culture. I totally agree with him in terms of cognitive function of arts since throughout time and place, without the artistic and aesthetic ways by using human brain and sensory, human society and culture would never have existed. As a tool of building cultures, the arts help us to notice the world and help our new creations including ideas, philosophies and technologies which can be evanescent settle down in the world and last for a long time.

“Art is a mode of human experience that in principle can be secured whenever an individual interacts with any aspect of the world. (Dewey)”

    In the chapter 2, Eisner talks primarily about the visions of art education such as DBAE, visual culture, creative problem solving, development of creativity and etc. Dealing with 7 visions, he suggests five principles that art education take into account. I mostly agree with his view except the first principle. He believes that art education should not sidetracked or attempt to justify its primary educational mission by focusing its efforts on outcomes even though art is kept marginalized because art is itself of value. I understand and respect his view but I doubt it. It sounds too ideal to bring the principle into the center of the education. Without visible outcomes, police makers, schools, principles, teachers and parents who suspect its educational effectiveness would not recognize the value of art education. Sadly enough, because of this reason, many educators and art teachers have been trying to show and prove the effectiveness of arts in education in order to convince the people. I believe unlike Eisner’s view, art educators and teachers need to scientifically research, provide scientific  outcomes and persuade the distrustful people because it is almost only way to establish arts as a main curriculum in education.              
      
   Freedman’s chapter deals with how visual art are related to visual culture and how we understand and use visual culture educationally. Pointing out the current changes, he describe visual culture is about our everyday lives and experiences.

“However things have changed fine art is still critically important but it is only one form of visual culture worthy of study. Visual culture as a whole must be seen as real in the sense that it is a major part of everyday experience. People cannot only speak freely; they can visually access, display and duplicate, computer manipulate and globally televise.(Freedman”)   

   As he points out that visual culture is much more informal than fine art in terms of traditional education, visual culture would be considered and understood as not only educational concepts but also the aspects or tendency of society. In terms of that, I agree with him that visual art places in the visual culture and it doesn’t matter whether visual culture education takes place inside or outside the school because art education dealing with visual culture helps to develop rich meanings through life experience.  

He indicates the following concepts as foundations of teaching visual culture.

1)     Reconceptualizing the field
2)     Meaningful aesthetics
3)     Social perspective
4)     Interactive cognition
5)     Cultural response
6)     Interdisciplinary interpretation
7)     Technological experience
8)     Constructive critique

     Among these factors, I was impressed by the first foundation he indicates, reconceptualizing the field. I still remember when I was taking the art classes in the middle and high school. I was very confused by the variety of arts and classification of arts when dealing with textbooks focusing on traditional view of arts. It looked like it really loves to classify and distinguish arts according to period, culture, media, style, technique, intent or purpose. I had learned arts and art history separately based on the classification. One thing obvious was that the more complicated classifications there were, the harder time I had for understanding. May be for that reason, I have forgotten almost everything I have learned. However, I am experiencing differently now. Even though I still have many things to learn about arts, I think I am pretty good at understanding and dealing with arts and its aspects. That’s because the classes in my degree program successfully offer a chance for me to think and experience arts wholly according to concept or BIG IDEA. So I believe art teachers need to reconceptualize the field of art by using the concept of visual culture in order to help student make connection with real world and approach arts more meaningfully.