This article “Seven principles for Visual Culture Eucation” by Paul Duncum gave me a great opportunity to think more about how the art teacher teaches Visual culture to students at today’s classroom. The seven principles which are power, ideology, representation, seduction, gaze, intertextuality and multimodality are well classified to apply to the current tendency of Visual culture in Art education.
According to Duncum, among seven principles, power is the key principle which is about when we encounter images, who has the power to make us get their message, even though power could be exercised by viewers. He also emphasizes that Visual culture is strongly connected with ideologies that reveal various thoughts, emotions and all our lives. Ideology could be anything and everything to create a way of thinking for showing or transmitting key messages creator intended through imagery. Representation is the method to express specific ideologies such as stereotyping which is the negative case of representation. He suggests that students have to look what is marginalized or left out as well as what is represented and how. Seduction is about sensory related to being beautiful or attractive every image pursues. Ducum believes that sensory lures are significant because they act to wrap ideologies in pleasurable forms that make rejecting ideologies more difficult. The gaze is focusing on how we look at images and the circumstances under which we look. He explains about gaze that we are invited by images to see in a particular way, but we also come to them with already existing relationships to what we see. He points out that with intertexts, images are connected irrespective of historical categories so intertext provide us opportunities to explore power, ideology, representation and the gaze. Multimodality involves a new way of thinking about interpretation. Every meaning art has could be changeable depending on situation or other effects, even if image is not changed.
I searched Korea advertisements and found two for critical analysis that utilizes Duncum’s “Seven Principles” While I was looking carefully at these PSAs, I found some points Duncum’s all principles involves. I would like to apply seven principles to these advertisements as much as I can.
Translation to English: Mommy, What is the name of that grass?
Power- The government of Korea
This is a public service advertisement. The bottom of logo symbolizes the institute which belongs to the government and mainly produces PSA so I can easily catch who create this advertisement without thinking. However, if there weren’t the logo, I can still guess who made this. It might be related to authorities who want to encourage people to reduce the plastic bag.
Ideology– Against environment pollution
It is persuading viewers to preserve our environment. It is close to progressive ideology.
Representation- They use the photo that green plastic bag is buried in the ground and some part of bag reveals a little bit with real grass. There is some possibility for the young to be confused what kind of grass that is. To emphasize the negative possibility, they put the copy “Mommy, What is the name of grass?” into the image. I think this representation is pretty brilliant but a little bit weak.
Seduction- This image is a bit boring but a good combination of colors which are brown and green.
Gaze- Without the text, the image could still touch most viewers’ perception about what was going on the picture or why this happened. It requires pretty popular knowledge about the pollution of our environment.
Intertextuality- I think the image, text and graphic are well connected with each other.
Multimodality- How could this image have a different meaning? Through using a different text like “Mommy, I made the grass all by myself”, somebody would make an advertisement of private art institution for children.
Translation to English: Do you think living beings could be a toy?
Power- The Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals
Through this advertisement, they argue that people shouldn’t treat their pet like a toy which is easily abandoned without the sense of guilt. Nowadays, in Korea, the issue about abandoned pet has been controversial.
Ideology– Protecting pet from people’s abandon
It is also close to progressive ideology related to the argument that all living beings have to have same right as human being’s.
Representation- They paste a little puppy into the photo which depicts the inside of toy bending machine in which toy dogs are waiting for new owner. The puppy is about to be chosen by somebody. Its expression is strong enough and makes viewer feel sympathetic to the little thing.
Seduction- This image is interesting. Even if this talks about serious problem, it uses one of 3B(Baby, Beauty, Beast) which are most popular models in advertisement that easily attracts people’s attention.
Gaze- In the all around world, animals including pets are suffering from human. This information is fairly general and common these days so I believe, if someone gaze this advertisement, he or she easily grasps the message of advertisement.
Intertextuality- The image, text and graphic are well connected with each other. The text is not attractive enough to me though.
Multimodality- How could this image have a different meaning? Through using a different text like “Present a real puppy to yours, It is better idea than buying hundreds of toys”, somebody would make an advertisement for pet industry.
My questions are as follows.
1. How could art teachers deal with past issues and current issues in Visual culture at the same time and place?
2. Which part of Visual culture has to be taught to students?
What delightful images you have selected and what a treat for you to share your analysis! These images are great reminders that the world truly is a small place, and of the commonalities which all humans share.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Sheryl that you have made 2 excellent choices for analysis and that the issues are universal global concerns.
ReplyDelete