Discuss your pre-VTS assessments in general. Did you notice any commonalities among student responses? Reflecting upon Housen’s description of Stage 1 viewer, did you recognize characteristic anything during the pre-VTS assessment?
I implemented Pre-VTS Assessment with eight Korean kids. Yes, There are some commonalities among students’ responses. Most students recognized the several following points.
. The people in the picture are ice skating.
. They all look happy because they are smiling.
. Dancing people are being paired with opposite gender.
According to Housen’s description about Stage 1 viewer, accountive viewers are storytellers and using their senses, memories and personal association, they make concrete observations about a work of art that are woven into a narrative. While checking students’ answer papers, I realized that some can only see separated direct information from this picture without linking each description. Their answers tend to be simple like ice skating, cold weather or dancing. They might not know how to make good answers using their evidences or, maybe, the class atmosphere is too liberal to concentrate on making their own thoughts. However, few students showed me the capacity to make up a well-knited story using detailed narrative and their imagination based on their experiences.
One 5thgrade child interpreted that “people are practicing for some competition because they are paired and most women are wearing the skirts. It doesn’t normally happen to normal ice skating people. And their motions look more like they are dancing to some music. Another 4th grade child points out that “There are some people in the front of the river and in the back of river but there’s no people in the middle of the river so the part of water is not frozen enough.
I was very impressed by these two students’ brilliant answers. Also I guess that if this assessment could be implemented in the form of discussion like normal VTS class which provides a chance to share their ideas with other kids instead of writing on their own paper, better answers could come out through interacting with each other. From this expereice, I realized that active communication is also significant factor for successful VTS class.
Even though I learned a lot from this kind of first lesson with children, I had some difficulty during the lesson. Since the chapel of the church doesn’t have any equipment for showing the picture, it is hard for me to get attention from them. Besides, I implemented the lesson after the worship service so some children don’t want to participate. The class environment and atmosphere were bad for me to have a class. So I make alternative plans for upcoming classes. I will invite children to my house and have the lesson. I already got permission from the children’s parents and also prepared good equipments for the class. It is a much more private and comfortable place to me so I think I could be doing better next time.


This is a wonderful commentary.
ReplyDelete