Student Engagement and Learning
Describe student willingness to participate in the 3rd VTS discussion. Do they approach the discussions differently as they have gained experience with VTS?
Students’ willingness to participate is getting stronger as the classes are going on. In comparison with the first lesson, they are much more getting used to the lesson and their answers are becoming more profound and analytic. They looked like they totally understand what the VTS instruction requires them to respond.
Are individual student responses different from when they first began?
Yes. After experiencing several lessons, many of students who belonged to Stage 1 started to make casual relationship about their observations or ideas. I, sometimes, didn’t realize that I have to ask the second question “What do you see that make you say that?” because students already said about the reason why they think or guess like that.
Has the quality of discussion changing as students are gaining experience with VTS?
Yes. The quality of the discussion was changed. The more experiences students have, the better quality came out. They point out much more observations and try to connect and interact with many ideas.
Describe student interactions during the 3rd VTS discussion. How did this impact group meaning-making?
Once one student said about something, others tried to support or argue with that idea. Through agreeing or disagreeing, each of them participates in group meaning-making. And I found something interesting phenomena. The points many students want to stick to for a little bit longer time, tend to be detailed because many ideas are combined and connected by students.
What do you think students are learning /gaining from VTS participation?
I believe students learn and gain how to discuss, how to respect others’ opinions, how to interact and reach agreements and how to make casual relationship through interpreting the work of art.
What are you seeing that makes you say that?
They looked really passionate about meaning making process. They tried to be rational to prove their ideas are right or great. All of them were so excited to say their thoughts as well as to hear others opinions. Almost everyone didn’t want to finish the lesson after 20 minutes class.
Reflective Practice
What have you learned from teaching with VTS thus far?
I am getting so sure that VTS are totally new instruction to get all students involved to the discussion without fear or pressure. As students learned a lot from this instruction, I have learned that this kind of instruction can efficiently engage students and make them active and positive thinker. I also realized that teachers need not to teach but just facilitate for better lesson like VTS.
Are you able to use the questions and prescribed teacher behaviors comfortably?
Yes. I think I am doing better as I have experienced the classes. However, as I mentioned earlier, I am forgetting the second questions because students tend to explain why they think like that before asking the questions. I am wondering if it is okay for me to frequently skip the second question.
What challenges are you encountering as you implement VTS and incorporate it in your teaching?
I always have had a small class composed of five children so almost all students had many chance to talk about their ideas. This situation can easily make them compete in the discussion against each other. It could be a good one but some of them looked like they only argue with specific person’s ideas intentionally. What am I going to do when this happened again?
Are you surprised by anything that is occurring? How will these surprises impact your practice moving forward?
I had two new students who don’t have experience about VTS. And they were very quiet and passive for the first time. At first class with the picture 3.1, they hardly said anything. I tried to encourage them to speak but they didn’t and just watched the class. At the second lesson with the picture 3.2, they started to raise their hands and said about something. It was only few words but I felt their willingness to participate become awake. At the third lesson with the picture 3.3, they actively participate in the discussion. It was so surprising to me and I got to be sure that VTS is almost only one instruction all in the class can get involved.
Describe your confidence and competence using VTS at this time in your practice.
As I gained experience with VTS classes, I have felt confident and comfortable. And I am pretty sure that I am almost adapting to VTS instruction. However, I found some pattern of mine that I couldn’t find from last classes while I checked the recording. When I paraphrased something of students, I tend to mix few new evidences to support student’s ideas. Sometimes, this tendency was strong that I was letting them know what the students never mentioned. It caused because I think I was so excited to tell something about the work of art too.
Planning for the future
What do you want to work on as you plan for future VTS lessons?
As I mentioned, I will try to fix my wrong pattern of paraphrasing. I’d better consciously paraphrase without linking to my new ideas.
How do you think you can accomplish that?
Since I already know well about my behavior as a VTS facilitator, I will try to keep in mind that I only paraphrase based on designated students ideas but not my ideas. It could also be related to keeping neutral stance. I was so excited to support each student ideas that I didn’t control my feeling to talk about mine. To remind neutral stance, I have to read the manual again and have some practice for that.

As always, your ideas and reflections are insightful, Jooyoung! It is so fun teaching this class with all of you amazing students!
ReplyDeleteCombined and connected ideas that develop during the course of a VTS discussion are very exciting to watch. It's synthesis at its finest! As linking student responses becomes more comfortable to you in your teaching, students will begin to recognize this phenomenon as well. They actually look forward to working with their group to discover meaning; depend on them for a while, in fact. Finally, they gain the confidence to venture out on their own again; to examine art and ponder its meaning independently. It's a circle; they go from being independent, idiosyncratic viewers to eager and effective collaborators and finally to confident independent meaning makers. (That is, if they continue to look at and discuss works of art with this method.)
You mentioned that in your small group, there appear to be a few members who intentionally disagree with other members; as if competing. One thing you might try before the next discussion is to tell them that there is a new challenge for them; before disagreeing with a classmate, they must state one thing or aspect of the work that they agree with. For example, following this new pattern, a student might say, "I agree that the little girl in the painting appears to be related to the painter, but I disagree that he is her father. He looks to me like her grandfather. I think that because...." You, as the teacher, can create customized rules like that to diffuse rivalry. It doesn't take anything away from the process. It just reinforces respectful, democratic meaning making. It allows students to voice divergence, but might also make the disagreement seem less like an attack to the child who is being disagreed with. If you try it, let me (and your classmates) know how it goes. If competition is still a problem, we'll continue to search for solutions. (And any other VTSers reading this, feel free to jump in with suggestions!)
I smiled when you described the two new students that joined you and how, by the third image, they were comfortable and participating in the discussion. This speaks not only to VTS effectiveness at community-building but also your VTS facilitation skills and your ability to put students at ease with you gentle and enthusiastic style! Congratulations and awesome job!!!