Thursday, October 20, 2011

Blog Topic #11



Assessing  Engagement Learning:

•Describe student willingness to participate in the discussion.  Has this changed over time? If so, how?
Since I am working with a small group composed of 5 students, basically, they have more chance to speak than the students in the school classroom. I think this environmental factor really affects my student’s willingness. My students have shown strong willingness since the second class. The willingness would remain at similar level until they start to lose their interest. But I don’t think this going to happen.  

•What did students notice about the featured artwork?
I dealt with Image 5.1, 5.2 and 5.3 for the lesson. And I want to talk about the first lesson with Image5.1. The students noticed the subject including their costume, relationship, motion, and facial expression, the setting such as time, season, period, country, and background information. Based on these observations, some found the emotion things and some made up stories

•Did students list or interpret their observations? Are they offering evidence to support their interpretations without prompting?
Yes. Two students having few classes before tended to be close to the Stage 1 viewer. They easily listed what they see without saying evidence. On the other hand, the rest of students were completely accustomed to saying logically with a lot of supportive evidences. Even while I paraphrase, they continued to find the evidences and added new one.

•Describe student interactions during the discussion.  Are they linking their responses to those of others?  Are they disagreeing respectfully?  If so, how do liking & respectful disagreement impact the discussion?  The group?
Since the last class, students’ competition was getting tough during the lesson. It frequently occurred because of the environmental factor that they have many chance to speak. I could find positive things while the competition was getting sharp in terms of logical thinking. However, positive and opened interaction might be influenced by this in bad way. Some students showed they were too obsessed with disputing other’s view. I thought they could possibly make an agreement but they didn’t intentionally. And one student was feeling bad by continuing disagreement even though they were not too aggressive or rude.

•What did students learn from this discussion?
Even if there were arguments, students got to know how to disagree or refute logically. Suprising thing is that, without my intervention, they could discuss and debate on primarily points on the picture. Throughout agreeing, disagreeing and refuting, they definitely learn the way discussion works or how to make their ideas logical and powerful.
           
Reflective Practice:

•How did the VTS discussion feel and what did you learn by facilitating this lesson with your students?
I found deep and profound interpretation while arguing, but at the same time, the discussion could be stuck in only few points. So I tried to ease the tension and help them see and find what they didn’t notice yet by encouraging like “These are great points but why don’t we find new things in this picture?” It really worked. I learned from this experience how to handle the tension or strong argument.

•Were you able to use the questions and prescribed teacher behaviors comfortably? If you omitted or changed anything, what impact did it have on the discussion?  Why do you think that occurred?
Yes. I was familiar with the questions and prescribed teacher behavior. Since the last class, I provided some time for them to make their own conclusion by incorporating the ideas because I didn’t want them to easily forget what they have mentioned at the end of the class. I believe this attempt would be great at least for the small class.  

•Were you able to scaffold vocabulary through paraphrasing?  How might you reinforce this learning?
Yes. I intentionally tried to use various vocabularies while paraphrasing. And it was not perfect, but pretty good. I still strongly believe that listening to recording would be the best way to observe or analyze my speaking pattern, habits, the level and the type of vocabularies. Video recording would be better than voice recording but it is much harder so I will use voice recorder for the rest of the classes.

•Were there any surprises?  How will these impact your practice moving forward?
While listening to the recording, I was surprised by progress of one student named Yeyoing. At first, she looked passive and like she doesn’t have keen observation or interesting narrative, but she was really great at almost everything this time. Based on her keen observation and analysis, she made up great story and showed profound interpretation by using casual relationship. I was very impressed by her since my expectation has been not much from her.  It was encouraging to me.  
Planning for the future:

•What do you want to work on as you plan for future VTS lessons?
I haven’t been familiar enough with designated pictures before the class. I would like to take some time to think deeply about the pictures before next class.
  
•How do you think you can accomplish that?
I didn’t have difficulty to have lessons even though I didn’t preview the pictures. However, I want to care about the process before class. It would be great for me to guess what points students would mention and prepare technical or high level terms or cultural and historical information to efficiently paraphrase. This would be the best way to train myself as a VTS facilitator.  



3 comments:

  1. What are the relationship of the students in your group? Are they really familiar with each other?

    It sounds like your group can carry on a discussion and not rely on you to prompt them with a question after every statement. How do you feel your role as facilitator has changed since the beginning?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes. They are familiar with each other. They are attending same Korean church. As Philip Yenawine points out, I don't think VTS facilitator is a teacher so if there are some more interesting interactions without my intervention, I had better let them feel free to discuss. Through this process, they might learn how to discuss and how to make their ideas more logical. So I am perfectly okay with that unless they are too aggressive or the discussion takes long time.

    ReplyDelete
  3. You have mentioned many insightful things in this post. One thing you might try to soften competition is to set a rule, for one class, that each disagreement has to conclude with some sort of supportive statement or agreement......For example, "I disagree with Yeyoing that ______, but I understand how she might see ____ as indicating ______." Something of that nature? I've never tried it that way, but it just occurred to me that for one VTS lesson, it might serve to train students to be positive and support one another, even when they disagree.

    I liked your idea of considering higher level vocabulary that might be used as you review an image privately before the discussion.

    Great ideas!

    ReplyDelete