Tuesday, October 25, 2011

Blog Topic #12



Interior with Portraits, Thomas Le Clear (1818-1882). ca. 1865. Oil on canvas. 25 7/8 x 40 1/2 in. (65.7 x 102.9 cm). Smithsonian American Art Museum.
Interior with Portraits records the arrival of a new technological form of "virtual reality" into the painter's traditional territory. After daguerreotypes were introduced in 1839, people could have colorful, often life-sized paintings. This picture is unsigned and undated; what we can know about it comes from his family history.




Bar Italia, Paul Cadmus (1904 ~1999) tempera on wood 37 1/2 x 45 1/4 in. (95.2 x 115.0 cm)Smithsonian American Art Museum
Bar Italia satirizes the crowds of tourists in Europe during the postwar years, when Americans alone had the money to visit a continent devastated by the Second World War. The sidewalk café offers a full range of characters, including argumentative Italians, pudgy clerics, hustlers, old widowed crones, and a group of what the artist called "rather outrageous" gay men.


Reflect upon these questions on your blog before presenting the VTS lesson.

Why did you select this work of art?
I chose two images. I believe these two pieces can be included in the good images for VTS lessons Yenawine points out especially in terms of accessibility, captivation, narrative and diversity.  
I tried not only to pick good images satisfying the guide line but also not to choose what Yenawine considered bad images.   

Why do you believe it is appropriate for your students, considering their age, stage, interests, and abilities?
Yes. My students are from 4th to 6th grade and, among 5 students, three who has been working with me until the beginning of the semester are classified as Stage 2 and two students who recently participated is in the transition between Stage 1 and Stage 2. I expect that my students will be capable of appreciating and interoperating these works based on not only using their senses, memories and personal association but also observing and analyzing figures and background information.

In what way do you believe it will challenge your students?
First one, Interior with Portraits would not be challenging and it might be familiar with them since the work looks similar to what they have dealt with. In addition, the picture was created by the view of realism so that it doesn’t have much ambiguity, complexity which makes students confused. However, second one, Bar Italia would be challenging to them. First, it has a lot of figures so that there are much more things to observe. Second, since the artist satirically described the figures, students would not know how to understand satirical paintings. It is a little bit far from reality. Therefore, the second piece would be more challenging to them in many ways.  

What features/aspects of the work of art and its narrative do you believe students will notice? What might intrigue them?
I guess that my students would recognize the relationship, situation and emotion of figures, and the period, nation, historical information of the piece and artists intention. The Realistic descriptions like a photograph help the piece, Interior with Portraits attract my students. And  it used vivid colors to express the objects. I think this picture wouldbe appealing enough to my students.
In case of second piece, satirical expressions and interesting narrative would stimulate their curiosity about the piece. It might be hard for them to understand what is going on in this picture but they might soon make up various stories based on their personal perspective.  

2 comments:

  1. I absolutely LOVE these images, especially the second one! I would worry my students would talk about it for hours though! Do you find that students take a VTS lesson farther and longer when an image is more complex ? Thats seems to happen in my class room. :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. These are both very interesting images. The first one, I agree, is clearly within your students' grasp. I can see several possible narratives in the piece. The second one will definitely challenge them. Be sure to examine it carefully beforehand for anything that might be inappropriate for their ages. Sometimes, in such a full image, adult content can be hidden. Of course, it is usually the first thing that students notice and it's difficult to move a conversation beyond that aspect when it happens. Good luck!

    ReplyDelete