Visual Thinking Strategies II
SELF-ASSESSMENT ACTIVITY
Video # __3__ submitted by _ Jooyoung Ahn____ Date _Jan 23, 2011
INSTRUCTIONS:
View your own VTS lesson video critically. For each student response, place an “x” to document each facilitator behavior as it occurs from left to right. If a behavior does not occur during an interaction, leave the column blank. If a question or teacher behavior is not appropriate (ie Q#2 is not necessary if a student lists a simple observation w/out interpreting), place “NA” in
the corresponding column.
* I placed “NN” in the Q2 column if the second question is not necessary since the student provided the evidences.
Response
|
Gesture
|
Paraphrase
|
Q #2
|
Gesture
|
Paraphrase
|
Q#3
|
Example:
|
x
|
x
| ||||
1
|
x
|
x
|
NA
| |||
2
|
x
|
x
|
X
|
x
|
x
| |
3
|
x
|
x
|
NN
| |||
4
|
x
|
x
|
X
|
x
|
x
| |
5
|
x
|
X
|
x
|
x
| ||
6
|
x
|
x
|
NA
| |||
7
|
x
|
x
|
NN
| |||
8
|
x
|
x
|
NN
| |||
9
|
x
|
x
|
NN
| |||
10
|
x
|
X
|
x
|
X
| ||
11
|
x
|
x
|
NA
| |||
12
|
x
|
X
|
x
|
X
| ||
13
|
x
|
x
|
NN
| |||
14
|
x
|
x
|
NN
|
x
|
X
| |
15
|
x
|
x
|
NN
| |||
16
|
x
|
x
|
NN
| |||
17
|
x
|
x
|
X
|
x
|
X
| |
18
|
x
|
x
|
NN
| |||
19
|
x
|
x
|
x
|
X
| ||
20
|
x
|
x
|
NN
|
Reflecting on practice:
1. Based on the data recorded on the table above:
· Which facilitator behaviors are you using consistently and well? What impact is this consistency and skill having on the discussion?
Paraphrasing to the first response of the students and keeping a neutral stance were pretty good. As one of VTS strengths is to develop language skills, I think I provided a chance for students to learn higher level of expressions through paraphrasing. And I looked very supportive but kept a neutral stance to the every student.
· Which facilitator behaviors are you omitting or using less consistently or successfully? What impact is this having on the discussion?
I found that I omitted the second question many times. That’s because as the students have more experiences in VTS, they started to speak both observation and reasons at the same time. The most students of mine did that so, in that cases, I placed NN (not necessary) in the Q2 column. One more thing that surprises me is that I skipped the third question almost every time. My students raised their hands so often, so I felt like I don’t need to say Q#3. But I am not sure it is okay. Isn’t it the better idea for me to say Q#3 before calling on the next student even if I don’t need to seek a new one to speak since many students were already raising their hands?
2. What did you learn about your own practice while watching this video?
I have thought of a lot of points that I didn’t ever think of before assessing myself by using the assessment form. I think it might be better if I use more various gestures and strictly follow the VTS instruction.
3. What did you learn about your students’ engagement and/or participation while watching this video?
My students were passionately engaged in the discussion and look enjoying the whole process of VTS. Since they worked as a small group, every student got a lot of chances to speak. I personally believe a small group of students could be more passionate to participate since they would have more chances.
4. Did anything surprise you as the result of watching this video?
I was surprised that most students of mine got used to giving the evidences. That made me not to say Q#2. And I didn’t know that I hardly used Q#3.
5. Did the video reveal anything you might need to work on and how do you think you might be able to accomplish this?
As I said before, I better make sure I follow the instruction in detail. I will use three questions without omitting and skipping as much as I can if the usage was appropriate. I am also planning that I use more high level of vocabulary and expression. In order to do that, I would spend some time to preview the images before having the class. Through the process, I could think of not only expected answers and points but also a higher level of expressions which can improve the quality of the paraphrasing.
Blog Topic #1
After completing the self assessment as homework, the student will post answers to the following questions on the blog.
1. What did you learn about your current VTS skills from self-assessing video #3 from last semester?
It is a very beneficial experience to access my performance and facilitation in detail since I can analyze my strengths and weak points as well as have better understanding about the ideal facilitation. Before using this assessment form, I didn’t realize that I hardly use the Q#3. I also have met ambiguous moments I wasn’t sure whether it is okay or not. My students, for examples, tend to give evidences when speaking about their observations so I naturally skipped the Q#2. Or students participation was so good so I felt like I don’t need to say Q#3 “What more can we find?” since most students already expressed that they found new things by raising their hands.
2. What do you think you are doing well? (What did you see that makes you say that?)
I think I was good at paraphrasing and linking. Through the paraphrasing, I showed a higher level of structures or expressions of languages about what they say before. As the students give the evidences, if the expression in terms of grammar or structure is not appropriate, I adjusted the expressions more logical and more suitable. In the case of linking, I focused on it when students disagreed or agreed in order to remind all students the discussion points. I was also pretty good at keeping a neutral stance. Even if I kept smiling and looked pretty supportive, I didn’t express compliments, surprises or suspicions to the particular students.
3. What do you think you need to work on? (What did you see that makes you say that?)
I am planning to use the higher level of vocabularies and expressions since my new students are older than the previous students. Through this process, I would like to provide students a chance to learn new vocabularies and get used to them. Keeping checking my facilitation, I would rigorously follow the VTS instruction in detail.
4. What behaviors/skills will you focus on developing and or improving during the semester?
I would like to improve the gestures used in the discussion. I basically used only one hand to point to the part of image but it looked boring and too repetitive. I can use the different kinds of gestures which can get attention of the students and efficiently support what I am saying. And I would focus on developing better paraphrasing by using the higher level of vocabularies and expressions so I am planning to spend more time to preview the images.
Wow! Look at all of the "NNs" in your log! YOur students clearly learned what VTS was about last semester! Yeah! If students answer Question #2 without you having to ask them, it is fine to leave it out. Just pay attention and be sure to use it when a student doesn't provide evidence.
ReplyDeleteIn answer to your question about Question #3, Housen & Yenawine say that it is important to use Question #3, even when hands are in the air. It communicates that the conversation isn't over after a student responds and keeps pushing them to go back to the image and keep looking. You can ask it before you call on the next student or you can ask it of the next student you call on. I've seen it both ways and it works either way. Just keep asking it. See if it makes a difference, too. (If your answer is "yes," what do you see that makes you say that?)
I agree that the smaller group with many opportunities to respond contributed to the students' enthusiasm and passion for the process! You were a warm and welcoming facilitator, too, so give yourself some credit as well!