![]() |
| Execution JaneGrey |
How does it compare to your introductory image for this curriculum unit?
. In terms of complexity & details?
Compared to the introductory image, this image contains much more complexity. It certainly requires higher level observation because the figures and objects are more and complex and narrative would be more difficult to be understood than the first image. As I expected about this image, my students tried to understand this image through figuring out clues. They showed higher level thinking and interpretation based on their historical and religious knowledge during the discussion. Now, they seem to be more excited about challenging works.
. In terms of ambiguity & meaning?
This image could have less ambiguity than the first image since while first image shows victim of fear but doesn’t show the object of fear, this image shows both. But I believe this image has enough ambiguity to be open to multi interpretations because the period, place, situation and figures of this image are much more unfamiliar to my students than the introductory image. My students’ interpretations were much more complex and profound than those of the first image.
. In terms of cultural &historic diversity?
The introductory image doesn’t require high cultural and historical knowledge for them to understand. It was pretty general and universal. On the other hand, this image contains strong cultural and historical factors so my students tended to easily depend on their knowledge which seemed to be gained from school curriculum or reading rather than their experience.
. Were responses to IMAGE #3 qualitatively or quantitatively different in any way?
I was very impressed by the way they interpret this image based on religious knowledge. Even though they are all Christians who have been strongly influenced by Christianity from very young age, most of them seemed to know and understand provincialism of Christianity. Many students believed that the reason the woman is executed is because she committed religious sins like she might have prohibited religion or have troubles in church community.
. Has the integration of VTS discussions into this curriculum unit impacted the student art products in any way? Has the integration of VTS discussions into this curriculum unit impacted student attitudes or motivation in any ways?
Yes. The reason I initially chose this image is because I want to have my students deal with the image which contains both the victim of fear and the object of fear. Through interpreting this image, I hoped my students have a better understanding about correlation of fear. And I am pretty sure that, through this experience, my students could get inspiration and expand meanings for making two types of artworks as the victim of fear and the object of fear. Students tried to understand the women considered as victim of fear in this image and were willing to find connections with the people considered as the object of fear.

I'm always interested in seeing the next image in your unit series. This piece is charged with a wide range of emotion and does a great job of portraying both sides of fear. I can just imagine the response it created with your students!
ReplyDeleteI smiled when you said of your students that "Now, they seem to be more excited about challenging works." YEAH! I can't help but wonder if students get excited about more challenging math problems or reading assignments! (I think I know the answer and it is "No.") It's very exciting that they look forward to interacting with stimuli that demand more cognitive effort from them. I'm still smiling!
ReplyDeleteI am fascinated, too, at the way you are presenting the big idea of FEAR to your students; not only from the perspective of the victim, but also that of the object of fear. You are designing a very strong instructional unit!