. Discuss strengths of this VTS application & approach to critique/assessment
Since my class is composed of only 4 or 5 students and they all are familiar with VTS for almost a year, this VTS application for a peer critique could make my students ease and lessen their tension and fear about the evaluation process. Besides, because VTS discussion focuses primarily on observing, understanding and interpreting rather than critically assessing a work of art, this approach enables my students to actively participate in the discussion for a peer critique. Students’ engagement was pretty good too.
. Discuss the weaknesses of this VTS application & approach to critique/assessment
It is hard for me to find weaknesses of this VTS application because I don’t have any previous experiences with critique so I could hardly compare and contrast with any other ways of critique. However, I could find a few things that are a little bit confusing. Unlike I expected, students’ works are not so appropriate to VTS discussion. That’s because I think while the previous VTS images were carefully chosen according to students’ stage, age and level, these students’ works weren’t selected by VTS facilitator. Students’ art works seemed to be more abstract and ambiguous and have less narrative than the previous VTS images.
. How did students respond to this VTS application/assessment approach?
As I mentioned earlier, the images of students’ art works were not appropriate to the beginning viewer, the quality of discussion seemed to be somewhat debased. I modified the discussion a little bit to make it more interesting to students. I gave a chance for each creator to response to peer’s ideas, add ideas or explain his or her intention. Even though students were excited about this process, I am really wondering if it would be really okay. I am worried because it seems to slightly break one of VTS principles, open-ended discussion.
. Would you repeat this approach in the future with this unit of other units?
. If so, what modifications might be warranted to make it more successful?
I would try this approach again in my future classroom. However, I need to be more careful when using this approach. I personally think the artworks involving strong narrative would be more appropriate to VTS as a peer critique if students are elementary level. To make this approach more successful, I think I need to have a better understanding about critique through studying and experiencing the critique process. It would be a good idea for me to get some advice from my colleagues who are professional art teachers.


When I used VTS to critique student work I first selected a piece of work created by a student in a different classroom. It was detailed just enough, and had a strong narrative. The experience was quite successful, lasting about 15 minutes. When we broke into small groups it was definitely more of a challenge. The stronger the narrative of the student work, the more successful the VTS conversation. I asked students to consider changes they might make to communicate their message more clearly. I asked them to reflect on the images we had looked at in the past and to think of the ways that art can tell stories.
ReplyDeleteI asked the students whose work was being VTSed not to speak. Like you, I wasn’t sure quite how to handle it. I asked them to listen very closely to what was being said. Throughout the design process I kept stressing to my students that their tile designs had to tell a story, a story of change. With that in mind I felt like they should understand that they were trying to interpret what story of change their classmate’s work was depicting.
I agree that the student created collages would be more abstract and ambiguous than the exciting images you have shown throughout your unit. How did you focus student thinking on the studio assignment? Do you feel that their work illustrated an understanding of your big idea? I wonder if it would be helpful for the group to VTS a collage which you have created as an example?
In my opinion, sometime it’s okay to go VTSesque, to ‘slightly break’ one of the principles if the end result justifies the means.