Tuesday, June 5, 2012

Research Translation 1

Cognition and Emotions in the Creative Process

RESEARCH PROBLEM

In this article Gnezda (2011) argues that understanding complex neurological and emotional operations would be helpful to fully understand and foster students’ creativity since creativity is a cognitive-emotional manipulative experience that is accessible to all people (p.47). The author states the importance of the research and defines the variables and important terms clearly such as creativity, creative thinking, creative thinker and creative process.


LITERATURE REVIEW
The reviews of previous research are well organized. The author cites all relevant sources which support and reinforce his arguments. The half of cited sources is from the current researches but rest of them is from the researches of the beginning to late of nineties.      


RESEARCH QUESTIONS or HYPOTHESES
I think Gnezda stated somewhat clearly his research question. “Why individuals differ in the quantity of creative output and the ease with which they engage in creative processes is unclear?” (p.48). He also suggests a few hypotheses related to creativity but they are somewhat ambiguous. Relying on other researchers or outcomes of researches, she basically develops her major arguments.

DATA SOURCES/SAMPLING
Instead of clearly showing her own data sources, the author uses and borrows data and outcome of the previous researches. Because of that, the method of selection is not clearly described but the data she provides is easy to understand.

MEASUREMENT TOOLS
I could not find the measurement tools in this article. Validity and reliability data are not reported.

METHODOLOGY/PROCEDURES
The author did not provide adequate descriptions of the methods and procedures. There is not appropriate statistics for the research. If she provides her own data, measurement tools and statistics or explain about the methods and procedures for the study, the arguments in the article would seem to be more persuasive and scientific.    

RESULTS
There are not actual results in this article even though the authors’ conclusions are understandable. However, the initial question “Why individuals differ in the quantity of creative output and the ease with which they engage in creative processes is unclear?” was answered. She said “creative thinking involves mental work that is different in style and brain activity than that used during other modes of thinking, such as logic or analysis.” Some of hypotheses were tested but they also rely on outcomes of other researches.

DISCUSSION
The conclusions are somewhat related to the hypotheses and research question however, it focuses primarily on the author’s statement as advices for art educators who want to foster students’ creativity. Even though this article suggests many great ideas to foster students’ creativity for art teachers, I realized this is not a good research article while working on this research translation. I chose this article because the topic is very interesting to me but, now I am confused whether this article could belong to the category of research article.  

REFERENCE
Gnezda, Nicole M. (2011). Cognition and Emotions in the Creative Process. Art Education 64 no1 Ja 2011 (pp. 47-52)

No comments:

Post a Comment