Thursday, November 29, 2012

Week 14 Expression & Context, Read & React

Reflect & Write – Part 1

Choose one of the quotes on the first page of the “Gude Notes” document to compose a thoughtful, reflective response. What are the classroom implications for this statement? Describe how this might related to your classroom experiences or how you predict this affecting classrooms of the future. Do you agree or disagree with her statement or stance? Provide evidences to support or illustrate your thinking through examples.

“It is our job as contemporary artist/educators to teach the most useful, complex, artistically sophisticated version of art education that we can now imagine.”

I think, in the above quote I chose, the phrase, “we can now imagine” is the most important and meaningful part in the sentence. It reminded me of what I have learned from various activities this course has allowed me to do. And I could make some connections between the quote and objectives of this course. I believe it is very important to help students express their ideas through new technologies and tools when teaching visual arts for young generation in this technology age. It is about new possibilities. So I would put more emphasis on contemporary art and new technologies and tools rather than fine art and traditional mediums and tools. I am not saying that fine art is not worth teaching. However, it would be a better idea to provide more chances for students to explore, create and imagine new things by using new tools. In terms of that, I would encourage my students to explore and utilize various digital technologies and software programs which can be used in art making process. I think arts education need not to fall behind the rapid change of society and the world to allow students to be fully engaged in authentic learning process. If arts education cannot fully reflect recent changes, students wouldn’t make any meaningful connection to the world where they belong to. Therefore, art teachers have to be open-minded on new changes of the world in order to bring the changes or trends to their own art classroom so that we can teach most useful, complex, artistically sophisticated version of arts that we can now imagine.

Reflect & Write – Part 2

Value one

Value: craft as a record of human experience and process over craft as a recipe for making an object

- What are the classroom implications for this value? What does this value look like “in action” in your classroom or how do you predict this affecting classrooms of the future.

It is very hard for me as a preservie teacher to understand 11 values and imagine and think about how I relate the values to my future classroom. Anyway, I chose the 8th value; craft as a record of human experience and process over craft as a recipe for making an object. The reason I chose this value is because it is very similar to my perspective on importance of arts education. I believe arts are great container which can hold and show human experiences, stories and ideas. This is why arts are attractive and impressive to us. Needless to say through art making process, we could not only express our ideas, thoughts and emotions but also reflect and learn ourselves, our society and world. It is completely high level of human activity. Therefore, I would focus on teaching how to express ideas and emotions from experiences instead of focusing primarily on teaching artistic techniques. In terms of that, motivation would be very important in my art classroom. Some students could be used to coming up with new ideas or expressing their emotions but some might have a hard time doing that. So, in my future classroom, I would try to effectively motive my students to get engaged in meaning making process. This is what I believe about authentic learning in arts education.

Value two

Value: engaging mess over keeping things neat


Do you agree or disagree with including this value in your curriculum? Is it important or not? Provide evidence to support or illustrate your thinking through examples. What are the classroom implications for this value? If adopted, what would this value like “in action” in your classroom or how do you predict this affecting classrooms of the future?

 The value I chose reminded me of my internship experience in art classroom of elementary school. One thing I was surprised is that art teachers needed to spend pretty much time organizing and cleaning things up. I haven’t thought the issue before I experienced art classroom as a teacher. Anyway, I realized many art teachers are struggling with not only creating fabulous curriculums but also organizing and making things clean. So I think it is important to keep things neat as well as to be engaged in messiness. Allowing my students to experiment and explore without obsession with cleanness, I would teach students how to efficiently organize art materials and tools and make them clean. In terms of that, art classroom should require freedom and responsibility at the same time. If there is too much freedom toward messiness, it could keep negatively affecting the following art making classes since materials and tools might not be in their place and it can create some distractions. This is also one of the important practices in art making. And it is required for effective learning in art classroom.


Read & Reflect

While reading Hetland’s two chapters and Olivia Gude’s two articles, I pondered how to teach arts and how to create my own art curriculum which could fit to young students in this age. I believe arts education is to basically teach students how to express. It could be anything like personal experiences, ideas, thoughts or emotions. It is also connected to meaning making process since the process allows students to reflect themselves and find meaning in their lives. Therefore, in learning arts, it is very important to think critically and creatively before art making. In other word, ideas are often more important than techniques in arts education. Without ideas, technique also could not be new and creative.

In visual art classes, students are taught to go beyond technical skill to convey a personal intention in their work. Learning to Express includes making works that exemplify properties that are not literally present, such as moods, sounds, and atmosphere. Learning to express also means making works that convey properties such as emotions, a sense of movement, or personal meaning. (Hetland)

In art classroom, how to motivate and inspire students is the key to engage students into meaning making process. Fully motivated students in art classroom can enjoy and to be fully engaged in artistic play. Through exploration and experiment, students could encounter surprises and meanings in terms of idea, medium or technique. According to Hetland, this is the process to learn to stretch and explore. Teachers need to let their play open-ended for encouraging students to keep investigating. Teachers also need to show supportive attitude toward students’ attempts and their exploration to make them take risks without fear. This could also be one of the effective ways to foster students’ creativity.

In the visual arts studio, students are asked, implicitly and explicitly, to try new things and thereby extend beyond what they have done before to explore and take risks, to be creative. When teachers encourage students to Stretch and Explore, they do not tell students exactly what to do. Instead, through the level of challenge in the tasks teachers set for students and through the responses teachers make as students work on those tasks, they urge students to experiment, to discover what happens, to play around, and try out alternatives. (Hetland)


In two articles, Olivia Gude discusses what kinds of values could bring to art education curriculum and how to utilize them in art classroom. As a perservice teacher, it is completely challenging to thoroughly understand the articles since I don’t have enough experience teaching arts in the field. Because of that, it is also hard to make meaningful connections. However, I was impressed by how much the art curriculum could be rich and profound and the way arts curriculum allows students to communicate with contemporary society. Her articles make me realize the importance of arts curriculum and keep thinking about how to create my own curriculum for future classroom.

Art curriculum is not a mere container of aesthetic and cultural content; a curriculum is itself an aesthetic and cultural structure. Students should be able to sense, examine, and explain the structure of the art curriculum. These explanations should emphasize important ideas and themes associated with traditional and contemporary artmaking practices. (Olivia Gude)

I agree with Gude that the essential contribution that arts education can make to our students and to our communities is to teach skills and concepts while creating opportunities to investigate and represent one’s own experiences-generating personal and shared meaning. Quality arts curriculum is thus rooted in belief in the transformative power of art and critical inquiry.

Thinking about postmodern principles and principles of possibility Olivia Gude suggests in the articles, I realized that creating good art curriculum requires high level of thinking, art teacher’s deep reflection of the value of arts education and awareness of our society. What art teachers believe could strongly affect students’ learning in art classroom.    

I believe in the possibility of a more playful, sensitive, thoughtful, just, diverse, aware, critical, and pleasurable society. 'They combine the sensibilities of artists with the social awareness of community organizers. If it is indeed true that our notions of the real and the possible are shaped in cultural discourses, art teachers have the potential to change the world. (Olvia Gude)

2 comments:

  1. Jooyoung,
    I like how you are always so thorough in your writing, your journalism back ground shows and is a great assest.
    I understand how you feel when trying to write about the real experience of having our own art room and having to create and then implement our own ciriculum.
    I like to just pretend I already do and then dream up how and why I would do or not do things.
    I liked that you used this quote form Gude, it is a good one!

    "Art curriculum is not a mere container of aesthetic and cultural content; a curriculum is itself an aesthetic and cultural structure..."

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Jooyoung! I loved what you said when describing your first value and how you related it back to your time in the elementary classroom during your internship. I have to agree with you. It seemed that the classroom that I observed was almost a dumping ground for students by their classroom teachers. We never had a break or a moment between grade levels to prep because the classes would always be lined up in the hallway before the class had left. It seemed that if we would have had extra time, such as five minutes, we would have been so much more productive both with content and with preperation. It is really hard to think up deeper and meaningful lessons for elementary schoolers, especially when you have no mental prep time between classes. It is so easy to fall into that lazy pattern of working with easy and messy lessons.

    ReplyDelete