Thursday, September 1, 2011

Blog Topic #4




l  Assessing Student Engagement & Learning:


Describe student willingness to participate in the discussion.
I had only six students in this lesson. They looked more interested in the discussion and showed good concentration this time as compared with the pre-assessment lessons. I found something interesting phenomena during the lesson. They frequently looked to compete with each other for proving that their own interpretation would be better than others. This was a good one because, through the process including continuous agreeing and refuting, they made the discussion more abundant and profound. Their strong willingness was encouraging to me, howeve, I feel confused when almost all students often raised their hands to speak their opinions since it is a hard work for me to check whether I provide equivalent chance to everybody.    


What did students notice about the featured artwork?
I had the lesson with the image 1-1. There were common points they all have noticed about the artwork and also controversial points students agrued. I enumerate the students’ opinions collected from the beginning of the discussion.  

Common points
. This is inside house.
. The girl in the bed is sick.
. The old woman is taking care of her.
. The owner of the house is going to church.
. Season would be spring or summer.
. The leaves the old woman hold are related to healing the girl.
. The owner of the house could use a sewing machine to make clothes.
. To remember family or parents, the owner hangs the pictures on the wall.

Controversial points
. The girl is an owner of the house vs The old woman is an owner of the house vs They live in this house together and this is the girl’s room.
. The old woman is a grandmother of the girl. vs The old woman is a just neighbor or therapist.
. It is evening. vs It is dawn.
. The picture on the wall is a portrait of the girl’s parents vs The picture on the wall is a portrait of the old woman’s parents.
. The boy is the girl’s brother vs The boy is not the girl’s family.
. The glasses belongs to the girl vs The glasses belongs to old woman.


Did students list or interpret their observations? (Why do you think that occurred?)
Some students only focused on describing pictures and listing their observation without trying to find the causal relationship in the artwork. Nevertheless, some of them showed keen powers of observation to find new things which were never found by others. For example, one student said the leaves the old woman hold seems same as the tree outside the window.   
On the other hand, several students seemed to be accustomed to interpreting the facts of the artwork and building a framework through using the most logical and accessible tools and linking evidences based on their observation. They consider that the facts in the artwork would be connected by each other and, eventually, imply what really happen to the picture.  
As Yenawine points out differences of viewers between Stage1 and Stage2, I believe it occurred because every student has a specific way of thinking and they are generally divided into two types which are storyteller or constructive viewer.

Describe student interactions during the discussion.
They kept interacting with each other and influencing other’s opinion by sharing their thoughts. Supporting or arguing on some points, they develop ideas on the points and I could observe the process they reach an agreement when discussion was almost over. Here, I have one example for that. This is the three students’ conversation during the discussion.

A: This room belongs to an old woman because the atmosphere of the room looks old-fashioned and there are full of old person’s stuffs such as old sewing machine, black and white picture and traditional or religious flowers.   
B: I don’t think this is an old woman’s room because the dress hanging on the wall is too small for the old woman to wear. The room might belong to the girl and the purse on the chair looks like it is for young lady.
C: It is possible that the girl and the old woman live together. It is a her room but there can also be old woman’s stuffs. Suppose that the old woman spend whole day taking care of the girl. She has to stay with her so the old woman moved her stuffs to the girl’s room.
A: It could be….
B: It makes sense.  
  
How did the discussion conclude?
 During the beginning of the discussion, there were various opinions based on students own way of thinking and observation. However, at the end of the discussion, students could narrow their differences in opinion. Most students agree that “The old woman is the girl’s grandmother taking care of her instead of her dead son or daughter who is the girls’ parents and they live together.”

What do you think students learned from this discussion?
They might learn how to express their own opinions efficiently, hear other’s opinion and respect other's ideas. They eventually seemed to learn to narrow differences through discussing the issues.

What did you observe that makes you say that?
I was impressed when I watched that students were voluntary involved in the discussion. Sharing opinions, supporting or refuting statements, students seemed to get easily used to the discussion environment than I expected. And they showed that they were learning how to see things from both a single perspective and different kinds of viewpoints.


l  Reflecting on Practice:

How did the VTS discussion feel and what did you learn by facilitating this lesson with your students?
The VTS discussion was so great. I have been fascinated by this totally new instruction and am sure that many students not only get the benefit from this but also enjoy participating in the discussion without fear that their thoughts could be wrong. Even though I am fully impressed by this experience, I wasn’t so satisfied about my performance. When I faced embarrassing moment that I didn’t expect, I don’t think I fully controlled the situation. For example, one student frequently kept standing and interrupting the discussion but I couldn’t restrict the behavior efficiently because I wasn’t sure whether strong restriction is good or bad.   

Were you able to use the questions and prescribed teacher behaviors comfortably? If you omitted or changed the questions or behaviors, what impact did it have on the discussion?
Yes, I believe I did. I tried to get used to the questions in both English and Korean. As manual recommended, I behaved that I am open-minded and accepting of any ideas to encourage students and paraphrase each person’s response. I also took a neutral attitude and let them talk in non-threatening circumstance.

Were there any surprise?
As I mention earlier, I was frequently surprised by student’s keen power of observation and profound interpretation.  

How might this initial experience impact your practice moving forward?
I felt confident and learned a lot from this practice. But there were some minor mistakes that I made. For instance, I didn’t remember every name, I didn’t introduce this VTS discussion to students and I didn’t know well how I can respond to students’ questions. I think I can fix these mistakes in the next discussion and I expect my next performance could be more natural than this time.    


l  Planning
What do you want to work on as you plan for future VTS lessons? How do you think you can accomplish that?
Among 6 students, for two children, speaking English is more comfortable than using Korean. So I had to speak both English and Korean. This situation also made me feel hard and disturbed efficient discussion because I wasn't prepared to this situation. I need to improve interpretation skills for the future VTS lessons. I’ll made a script which are mixed by English and Korean and master questioning and the performance skill in both language through repeated practicing. I'll make my thinking and performance more automatic.   

2 comments:

  1. First, let me say that I am so impressed that you are using BOTH English and Korean with this group of students. You are clearly providing them with bilingual art education and I wouldn't be surprised if your approach strengthens the Korean language skills of the students who prefer English at this time. You are clearly integrating your instruction and I expect that your comfort with the bilingual VTS discussions will increase, too!

    As far as checking to see if you have given equal opportunities for all of the children to contribute, don't feel like you have to remember since you have so much else to manage simultaneously: the questions, the paraphrasing, the linking and the two languages. It is perfectly fine, when you feel that certain students have been dominating the discussion, to acknowlege that they have many wonderful ideas but that you'd like to hear from classmates who haven't had a chance to speak or who haven't gotten to share as many ideas. Surprisingly, most of the very talkative children will recognize that you mean them and put their hands down. (Young children are surprisingly honest!) It is okay, too, to invite a quiet student to offer their ideas by calling on them. Sometimes a quiet child DOES have something to say, but may need a little coaxing. If you call on that child and he/she DOESN'T have an idea to contribute, tell the child that you can tell he/she is thinking hard and that you wil come back to him/her later. That assures the child that their participation is wished for, encouraged and valued.

    If there is a student who continually speaks out in my VTS discussions, I will first glance at them as I raise my own hand and touch my finger to my lips to remind them of how they should get my attention. If that doesn't work, I pretend I don't hear the disruptive child and call on a child who is raising his hand as I say, "I'm going to call on Billy because he is raising his hand and waiting quietly to share his great idea." As a last resort, I pause the discussion momentarily and explain to the offending student that I can't call on him because he isn't asking for my attention in the right way. See if any of those strategies work. You can also talk to the child in private afterward and explain your expectations and why those expectations are important and fair to his/her classmates.

    Remember, in VTS just as in Art, there are no mistakes, just DISCOVERIES! I am so impressed with your work! Nice job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. You are breaking new ground, at least with our group, conducting bilingual VTS sessions. What a lucky group of students to get to participate in this experience.

    My group is a little larger than yours, but I too had a couple of children who wanted to monopolize the discussion. I explained that I was going to try to give everyone a chance to share one time before I could call on someone who had already spoken. That seemed to satisfy the group. If a child blurted out, I ignored them, and as Mary suggested, praised another child for holding his hand up quietly.

    Don't be too hard on yourself, the more experience you gain, the more natural it will feel! :-)

    ReplyDelete